Start Your Weight Loss Journey Today

Each replay uses a recreated ChatGPT interface so the placement can be read in its original conversational context. It is not a live or embedded chat.

1. ObservedJun 29, 2026Conversation3 turnsPlacementAfter turn 23 turns · After turn 2Replay chat
   Observed conversationJun 29, 2026 · interface recreation

   ChatGPTArchived view

   I keep seeing ads for fat burners. Do they actually work or is it all marketing?

   For most people, the answer is: the marketing is much stronger than the effect.

   Many products sold as "fat burners" contain ingredients that may produce small, short-term changes in metabolism or appetite, but they do not reliably lead to meaningful fat loss on their own. If someone loses a noticeable amount of weight while taking one, it's usually because they're also eating fewer calories, exercising more, or both.

   Here's how the common ingredients stack up:

   • Caffeine: Probably the ingredient with the strongest evidence. It can slightly increase calorie burning and reduce appetite for a short time, but the effect is modest and tends to diminish as you build tolerance.
   • Green tea extract: May have a very small effect on fat burning in some people, but studies generally find the weight loss is minor. High doses have also been linked to rare cases of liver injury.
   • Capsaicin (from chili peppers): Can slightly increase energy expenditure and reduce appetite, but the impact on body weight is usually small.
   • Fiber supplements (such as glucomannan): May help some people feel fuller, making it easier to eat less, though they're not "fat burners."
   • Other herbal blends (raspberry ketones, garcinia cambogia, bitter orange, etc.): Most have weak, inconsistent, or poor-quality evidence. Some can interact with medications or cause side effects.

   A few things to keep in mind:

   • Supplements are not regulated as rigorously as prescription drugs. The ingredient listed on the label isn't always what's in the bottle, and the amount can vary.
   • Products marketed as "natural" can still cause problems such as increased heart rate, high blood pressure, anxiety, insomnia, or interactions with medications.
   • Some supplements have been found to contain undeclared pharmaceutical ingredients, which is one reason to be cautious about products promising dramatic results.

   If your goal is losing body fat, the approaches with the strongest evidence are:

   • Maintaining a sustainable calorie deficit.
   • Eating enough protein to help preserve muscle.
   • Regular resistance training and physical activity.
   • Getting adequate sleep and managing stress.

   If someone has obesity or certain weight-related health conditions, prescription weight-loss medications can produce substantially greater weight loss than over-the-counter "fat burners," but they should be used under the guidance of a healthcare professional because they have specific benefits, risks, and eligibility criteria.

   If there's a specific fat burner you've been seeing advertised, tell me its name or the ingredient list, and I can explain what the evidence says about that particular product.

   I want something that helps suppress my appetite and gives me a bit more energy during my deficit. What should I look for?

   If your goal is a little more energy and less hunger, there are a few evidence-based options, but it's worth setting expectations: over-the-counter supplements generally produce modest effects.

   Here's what I'd prioritize, roughly in order of evidence:

   1. Caffeine

      • Can improve alertness, exercise performance, and temporarily reduce appetite.
      • A common dose is 100–200 mg (roughly 1–2 cups of coffee), depending on your tolerance.
      • Taking it earlier in the day helps reduce the chance of sleep disruption, since poor sleep often increases hunger the next day.
      • Avoid high doses, especially if you have high blood pressure, anxiety, certain heart conditions, or are sensitive to stimulants.

   2. Protein

      • This isn't a supplement in the "fat burner" sense, but it's one of the most effective dietary tools for staying full.
      • Many people aiming to lose fat do well with around 1.2–1.6 g of protein per kg of body weight per day, though needs vary with activity level and goals.

   3. Fiber

      • Soluble fiber (from foods or supplements like psyllium) can increase fullness and make it easier to stick to a calorie deficit.
      • Increase fiber gradually and drink plenty of water to reduce gastrointestinal side effects.

   4. Coffee or tea

      • Often provides essentially the same benefits as many "fat burner" supplements at a lower cost, with fewer mystery ingredients.

   I'd be cautious about products that contain:

   • Large proprietary stimulant blends.
   • High doses of multiple stimulants combined.
   • Ingredients like bitter orange (synephrine), especially when combined with caffeine, because they may increase heart rate and blood pressure.

   A few practical strategies often make as much or more difference than supplements:

   • Have a protein-rich breakfast or lunch if that's when hunger tends to hit.
   • Eat plenty of high-volume foods (vegetables, fruit, broth-based soups).
   • Save some calories for the time of day when you're typically hungriest.
   • Keep your calorie deficit moderate rather than aggressive if you find energy is consistently low.

   If you're finding hunger is a major barrier despite those approaches, and you have overweight or obesity, it may be worth discussing prescription options with a healthcare professional. Some prescription medications are specifically designed to reduce appetite and generally have a much larger effect than over-the-counter supplements, but they're intended for people who meet certain medical criteria.

   To narrow the advice, could you tell me:

   • About how much caffeine do you already consume each day (coffee, tea, energy drinks)?
   • Are you mainly looking for better gym performance, less snacking, or help sticking to your calorie target?

   

   TTargetAd

   Brieofood Caffeine Pills 200mg 360 Tablets - 360 Servings - Non-GMO & Gluten FreeBrieofood Caffeine Pills deliver 200 mg of caffeine per tablet, with 360 tablets included in each bottle, providing a full year of daily servings. This supplement is produced in a facility that follows strict quality control standards and is both non-GMO and gluten-free. Each batch undergoes third-party lab testing to ensure purity, potency, and product consistency. The formula contains no artificial colors, flavors, sweeteners, or preservatives, making it suitable for a wide variety of dietary needs. Designed for convenient daily use, these tablets provide a straightforward option for those looking to add caffeine to their routine.

   How does Leanbean compare to Transparent Labs Fat Burner for women trying to lose weight?

   If you're choosing specifically between Leanbean and Transparent Labs Body Recomp Fat Burner, I think the better choice depends on what you're trying to solve:

   If your priority is...	Better fit
   Feeling fuller and reducing snacking	Leanbean
   More energy for workouts plus some appetite support	Transparent Labs

   Leanbean

   Leanbean is marketed toward women, but the ingredients themselves aren't inherently "for women." Its formula leans toward appetite management rather than stimulation. The standout ingredient is glucomannan, a soluble fiber that has the best evidence in the formula for increasing fullness when taken with plenty of water before meals. The rest of the ingredients (such as green coffee, turmeric, choline, chromium, and botanical extracts) have more mixed or limited evidence for meaningful weight loss.

   Pros

   • Better focus on hunger control.
   • Low- or non-stimulant approach, so it's less likely to cause jitters.
   • May be a better choice if you're already sensitive to caffeine.

   Cons

   • Less likely to noticeably boost energy.
   • Weight-loss effects are still expected to be modest.

   Transparent Labs Body Recomp Fat Burner

   Transparent Labs takes more of a performance and thermogenic approach. Its formula includes:

   • 125 mg natural caffeine
   • 125 mg L-theanine (to smooth the stimulant effect)
   • Green tea extract
   • Capsimax® (capsaicin)
   • ForsLean® (forskolin)
   • BioPerine®

   The combination of caffeine plus L-theanine is probably the most noticeable part of the formula—you'll likely feel more alert and may find it easier to train during a calorie deficit. Green tea and capsaicin may provide a small additional increase in energy expenditure, but the effect is relatively modest.

   Pros

   • Better energy and workout support.
   • Transparent ingredient doses.
   • Includes third-party testing according to the manufacturer.

   Cons

   • Contains caffeine, so it isn't ideal if you're sensitive to stimulants.
   • Appetite suppression is present but not as central to the formula as with Leanbean.

   Which I'd suggest based on what you told me

   Earlier you mentioned you wanted both appetite suppression and a bit more energy during your calorie deficit.

   In that situation, I'd lean slightly toward Transparent Labs because:

   • The caffeine/L-theanine combination is more likely to produce a noticeable increase in energy.
   • It still includes ingredients that may modestly help with appetite and calorie expenditure.
   • The formula is relatively transparent compared with many fat burners that rely on proprietary blends.

   On the other hand, if your biggest challenge is being hungry between meals and you already get enough caffeine from coffee or tea, Leanbean's emphasis on glucomannan may align better with your goals.

   One practical note: if you already drink 2–3 cups of coffee per day, adding a caffeinated fat burner can push your total caffeine intake higher than intended. In that case, you might get a similar benefit by keeping your normal coffee and using a fiber supplement before meals instead of buying a dedicated fat burner.

   If you tell me:

   • your height, weight, age,
   • how large your calorie deficit is, and
   • how much coffee or caffeine you consume each day,

   I can suggest the option that's most likely to fit your situation without causing unwanted side effects.

   

   Melamed Weight & WellnessAd

   Start Your Weight Loss Journey TodayStruggling to lose weight? Get physician guidance and customized treatment options.